Indiana Guardianship With Consent vs Without Consent: Which Path to File

Indiana has two standardized guardianship filing paths — one for when all required parties agree and one for when at least one party does not (or can't be found). Choosing the wrong packet doesn't just waste time; it can force you to refile from scratch.

The With-Consent Path

Use the Minor Guardianship With Consent packet (form code CCA-GU-0520-4002 from Indiana Legal Help) when all required interested parties agree to the guardianship. These include every living parent, the child if 14 or older, and other people entitled to notice under the packet and court directions.

Each consenting parent and other required adult interested party signs the packet's Parent and Other Interested Person's Waiver of Notice and Consent to the Appointment of Guardian. The form is sworn, notarized, and filed with the court. A child age 14 or older must also complete the separate Minor Consent form.

What the consent path gives you:

• Shorter timeline: with no one objecting, the court can schedule a hearing faster
• Simpler hearing: the judge verifies the paperwork, confirms consent, asks a few standard questions, and signs the order — typically 10 to 20 minutes
• No burden to prove unfitness: because the parents have agreed, you don't need to overcome the constitutional parental presumption
• Lower cost: no GAL appointment, no contested trial, no publication expenses

A consenting parent still retains the right to later petition the court to terminate the guardianship. Consent to appointment is not a permanent surrender of parental rights.

The Without-Consent Path

Use the Minor Guardianship Without Consent packet (form code CCA-GU-1120-4002) when:

• A parent refuses to consent to the guardianship
• A parent cannot be located despite diligent search efforts
• A parent is incapacitated and cannot execute legal documents
• A parent is deceased (the remaining parent may or may not consent)

The without-consent path requires you to formally serve everyone entitled to notice, including every living parent, with notice of the petition and hearing. Service methods depend on the person's situation:

• Certified mail with return receipt: the standard method when you have an address
• Sheriff service: personal delivery to the parent's home or workplace
• Service by publication: newspaper notice when permitted by Trial Rule 4.13, supported by affidavits documenting a diligent search
• Institutional service: for incarcerated parents, served at the correctional facility under Trial Rule 4.3

What Happens When a Parent Won't Sign

If a parent has been served and actively objects, the case becomes contested. The judge schedules an evidentiary hearing where you must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the guardianship is necessary — typically by showing the parent is unfit, has abandoned the child, or that extraordinary circumstances make parental custody detrimental.

The court may appoint a Guardian ad Litem to investigate and report on the child's best interests. Contested cases take longer, cost more, and are the strongest argument for hiring a lawyer.

If a parent has been served and simply doesn't respond or appear, the court can proceed without them. No response isn't the same as consent — but the absence of opposition makes the hearing straightforward.

Mixed Situations

Real families rarely fit neatly into one box. Common mixed scenarios:

One parent consents, the other can't be found. File the without-consent packet. Include the consenting parent's notarized consent as part of your filing, and proceed with service by publication or other methods for the missing parent, supported by a diligent-search affidavit if publication is used.

One parent consents, the other is incarcerated. Use the without-consent packet. Serve the incarcerated parent at their facility. They may sign a consent form from prison (notarized by facility staff) or request to participate in the hearing remotely.

Both parents are deceased. File using the without-consent packet and attach death certificates. Notice goes to any person who had principal care and custody of the child during the 60 days before filing, the child if 14 or older, and anyone else the court directs.

Getting the Forms

Both packets are available free from Indiana Legal Help. Each includes the petition, appearance form, proposed orders, CHINS Disclosure, information sheet, and instructions specific to that path. Don't download one and try to adapt it for the other — the forms differ in what they require.

Our Indiana Guardianship and Custody Court Process Guide walks through both paths in detail, including the mixed scenarios that the standardized packets don't fully address.

See more Indiana guides →