Indiana Guardianship vs Custody vs Power of Attorney: Which One Do You Need?

Three Options, Very Different Results

Indiana relatives raising a child can get legal authority through guardianship, custody, or a power of attorney. Each serves a different purpose, lasts a different length of time, and affects the parents' rights in different ways. Choosing the wrong one wastes time and money — or leaves you without the authority you need when the school or hospital asks for documentation.

Custodial Power of Attorney (No Court Required)

Under IC 29-3-9-1(c), a parent can sign a notarized document delegating custodial, healthcare, educational, and property powers over a child to another adult for up to 12 months (longer if the parent is on active military duty). No court filing is required.

Best for: Short-term arrangements where the parent cooperates — deployment, medical treatment, temporary work relocation. The parent can revoke the POA at any time in writing.

Limitations: It expires. It depends entirely on the parent's willingness. Some institutions are reluctant to accept it for major decisions. It does not change custody or create any court order.

Guardianship (IC 29-3 — Probate Court)

A guardianship is a probate court proceeding where a judge appoints you as guardian of the child's person, estate, or both. It does not terminate parental rights. A parent seeking to end a third-party guardianship must first show that termination is in the child's best interests and that a custody factor has substantially changed. If the parent meets that initial burden, the guardian must show by clear and convincing evidence that continued placement with the guardian substantially and significantly serves the child's best interests.

Best for: Long-term arrangements where you need comprehensive authority — school enrollment, medical consent, benefits applications, financial management — and there is no existing dissolution or paternity case.

What it requires: Filing a petition, serving notice on all living parents, completing background checks, attending a hearing. The court must find the appointment is necessary for the child's care and supervision. The guardianship lasts until the child turns 18, though it can be extended to age 22 by joint petition.

Nonparent Custody (IC 31-17-2 — Family Court)

Third-party custody is a family law action where the court evaluates placement against the best-interests-of-the-child factors. It can be filed as a standalone action or as an intervention in an existing dissolution or paternity case.

Best for: Situations where a prior dissolution or paternity case already exists, or where you want a custody arrangement within the family law framework rather than probate.

What it requires: The same constitutional parental presumption applies. If a parent contests, the nonparent must show by clear and convincing evidence that placement with the nonparent substantially and significantly serves the child's best interests. The court is not limited to proof of parental unfitness, acquiescence, or a strong emotional bond.

Side-by-Side Comparison

How to Decide

If the parent is cooperative and the situation is temporary, start with a power of attorney. If you need lasting authority and there is no open family case, guardianship is usually the path. If there is an existing dissolution or paternity proceeding, third-party custody may be the direct route.

The Indiana Guardianship and Custody Court Process Guide walks through both the guardianship and custody pathways — the forms, fees, notice requirements, hearing preparation, and post-appointment duties — so you can choose the right option and follow through.

See more Indiana guides →