Dependency Court vs Probate Guardianship in California: Which System Are You In?

Two Systems, One Goal, Very Different Rules

When a California child needs to live with a relative, the legal pathway depends on whether the child is in an active child-welfare case and what legal authority the caregiver needs. If Child Protective Services (CPS) removed the child from the parents, the case is in juvenile dependency court. If the relative stepped in privately — because a parent is incarcerated, in treatment, or unable to care for the child — the relative may petition for probate guardianship when a court order is needed.

The distinction matters because it determines which court supervises the placement, what financial support is available, and what ongoing obligations the caregiver has.

Juvenile Dependency (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 300)

In the dependency system, the county child welfare agency files a petition alleging that the child has been abused, neglected, or abandoned. The juvenile court takes jurisdiction over the child and decides where the child will live. If the court places the child with a relative, that relative becomes a foster caregiver and must go through Resource Family Approval (RFA) — a comprehensive home-approval and licensing process administered by the county.

Key features:

• The county initiated the case, not the caregiver
• RFA includes background checks, home inspections, training, and ongoing oversight by the county agency
• The caregiver receives foster care payments (basic rate, plus specialized rates for children with higher needs)
• The dependency court retains jurisdiction and conducts regular review hearings
• If the relative obtains guardianship to exit the dependency system, they may qualify for Kin-GAP (Kinship Guardianship Assistance Payment), which provides monthly payments that can be higher than CalWORKs

Probate Guardianship (Probate Code Section 1500)

In the probate system, the relative files a petition in the Probate Division of the Superior Court. There is no CPS involvement and no county agency initiated the case. The relative petitions because the parents are unavailable, incapacitated, or consent to the arrangement.

Key features:

• The relative files independently — no agency involvement required
• The court assigns an investigator (not the same as RFA), who conducts a home visit and background checks under Probate Code Section 1513
• The filing fee is $435, with a fee waiver available based on the child's income
• The caregiver does not go through RFA and is not a licensed foster parent
• Financial support comes through CalWORKs non-needy caretaker grants, CalFresh, and Medi-Cal — not foster care payments
• Kin-GAP is not available because the child was never a dependent of the juvenile court

The Financial Gap

This is the sharpest difference. Dependency-system placements with RFA can access federal foster care funding and Kin-GAP, which pay substantially more than CalWORKs child-only grants. A probate guardian raising the same child with the same needs receives less financial support because they are outside the dependency system.

It is a well-documented inequity. But it is also the reality of how the programs are structured. You cannot file for Kin-GAP without a prior juvenile dependency case, and you should not file a CPS report just to access dependency-system funding.

When the Systems Overlap

If a child is the subject of an active dependency proceeding under Welfare and Institutions Code Section 300, the dependency court exercises exclusive jurisdiction over the child's custody and placement. You cannot file a parallel probate guardianship. If you are a relative who wants to care for a child in the dependency system, you participate in the dependency proceedings and seek placement through the county agency.

If there is no CPS case, probate guardianship is one court route for relatives who need a formal court order; some school, medical, or caregiving needs may be addressed through non-court arrangements.

Occasionally, a relative caregiver is already in a probate guardianship when the child becomes the subject of an active dependency proceeding. In that situation, the dependency court's jurisdiction supersedes the probate court, and the case may be transferred or consolidated.

Resource Family Approval Is Not Required for Probate Guardians

A common point of confusion: some relatives hear about RFA and assume they need it to become a guardian. They do not. RFA is a foster care licensing process specific to the dependency system. Probate guardians undergo a separate investigation under Probate Code Section 1513 — a home visit and background check, but not the full training and licensing regimen of RFA.

Choosing the Right Path

If CPS has filed a dependency petition and the juvenile court has taken jurisdiction, you are in the dependency system and work with the county agency. If no dependency case is pending and you need a formal court order for a private caregiving arrangement, probate guardianship may be the appropriate court route. The California Guardianship & Custody Court Process Guide covers the probate process from petition through post-order obligations, including the financial benefits available to probate guardians.

See more California guides →