Pennsylvania Kinship Care vs Foster Care Benefits: What's the Financial Difference?

The financial gap between informal kinship care and formal foster care in Pennsylvania is stark, and it's something most grandparents discover only after the child has been in their home for months. One caregiver described the trade-off this way: "Kinship placement is far more relaxed in my experience, but the kids will not get the financial benefits they would with a licensed foster parent."

Here's exactly how the money works across the three main arrangements.

Informal Kinship Care (No Child Welfare Involvement)

This is the most common arrangement — a grandparent or relative takes in a child through a private family agreement, without the county child welfare agency placing the child. About 70% of kinship caregivers nationally are in informal arrangements.

What you get:

• Child-Only TANF: $174–$215/month per child (varies by county group), caregiver income excluded
• SNAP: Household food benefits (caregiver income counts)
• Medical Assistance / CHIP: MAGI household and tax rules determine whose income counts; a relative caregiver's income is generally excluded under non-filer rules
• Caregiver Support Program: Up to $600/month reimbursement if caregiver is 55+ (through Area Agency on Aging)
• Child Care Works: Subsidized childcare (household income counts, work requirement applies)

What you don't get:

• Foster care maintenance payments
• SPLC (Subsidized Permanent Legal Custodianship) monthly subsidies
• Automatic categorical Medicaid (you get MAGI-based Medical Assistance instead — same practical coverage, different eligibility pathway)

Formal Kinship Foster Care (Child Welfare Placement)

When the County Children and Youth Agency (CCYA) places a child with a relative through the child welfare system, the relative becomes a kinship foster parent. This typically happens after a child abuse/neglect investigation where the agency determines the child can't stay with the parent.

What you get:

• Foster care maintenance payments: Monthly board payments set by the county, which are significantly higher than TANF child-only grants. Exact amounts vary by county and child's age, but state minimums start well above TANF rates.
• Categorical Medical Assistance: Automatic — no income test, no MAGI evaluation.
• Clothing and personal needs allowances: Part of the foster care maintenance rate.
• Caregiver Support Program: Still available if you're 55+.
• Training and support services through the CCYA.

What it requires:

• Your home must be approved or licensed as a foster home (background checks, home study, clearances)
• The CCYA holds legal custody of the child — you have day-to-day care authority, but the agency makes legal decisions
• You participate in case reviews, court hearings, and permanency planning
• The goal is reunification with the parent unless a court formally rules that out

What you give up:

• TANF child-only grants (you can't receive both foster care maintenance and TANF simultaneously)
• Full decision-making autonomy over the child's care

SPLC (Subsidized Permanent Legal Custodianship)

SPLC is Pennsylvania's guardianship subsidy — a middle path that gives you legal custody with ongoing financial support. It exists only for children who entered care through the child welfare system, after a court determines that reunification with the parent and adoption are both off the table.

What you get:

• Monthly SPLC payments: Negotiated between you and the CCYA, up to the foster care maintenance rate the county would have paid.
• Medical Assistance: Automatic categorical Medicaid for Title IV-E SPLC; MAGI-based for state-funded SPLC (same practical coverage either way).
• Legal custody: You become the child's legal custodian and make all decisions.
• Successor custodian designation: You can name a backup custodian in case you become incapacitated.

The catch that matters most: The SPLC agreement must be fully executed — signed by both you and the CCYA — before the court awards custody. If you go to court and get a guardianship order first, without an SPLC agreement already in place, you permanently lose eligibility for the subsidy. This cannot be applied for retroactively.

Financial offsets: If the child receives Social Security survivor benefits or SSI, the monthly SPLC payment is reduced dollar-for-dollar by that amount.

The Numbers Side by Side

Which Path Makes Sense

For most grandparents who stepped in on their own: start with informal kinship programs (TANF, SNAP, Medical Assistance, CSP). These require no agency involvement and no licensing.

Formal foster care only enters the picture when the county child welfare agency is already involved. You can't opt into foster care payments on your own — the CCYA initiates the placement.

If the CCYA is involved and permanency planning is moving toward you as the long-term caregiver, make sure an SPLC agreement is in place before any court custody order is entered. This is the most expensive mistake in the kinship benefits system, and it's irreversible.

The Pennsylvania Kinship Financial Help Guide walks through every program and how care arrangement affects eligibility, with a decision tree showing which benefits to file for based on your situation.

See more Pennsylvania guides →