Guardianship vs In Loco Parentis Manitoba
Two Paths to the Same Benefits
Manitoba kinship caregivers have two main ways to formalize a care arrangement: a signed In Loco Parentis agreement (no court required) or a guardianship order from the Court of King's Bench. Both open the door to EIA Section 5(1)(f) child assistance and the Canada Child Benefit. Neither one is automatically "better" — the right choice depends on your situation.
The In Loco Parentis Agreement
This is a document from Legal Aid Manitoba where the biological parent and the caregiver both sign to confirm that the caregiver is acting in the place of a parent. It was introduced by EIA Directive #2017-20 to replace the older "Guardianship Agreement" form.
What it gives you:
- Satisfies EIA documentation for Section 5(1)(f) child-only financial assistance
- Serves as proof of care for CRA Form RC66 (Canada Child Benefit transfer)
- Allows day-to-day caregiving decisions (school pickup, routine medical visits)
- Free to obtain through Legal Aid Manitoba
What it doesn't give you:
- No formal legal decision-making authority — the parent retains legal rights
- Revocable by the parent at any time without court involvement
- Not universally recognized by all schools, hospitals, or government agencies
- No ability to enforce child support from the parents
The In Loco Parentis path works well when both parents cooperate, when the arrangement may be temporary, and when no institution is demanding a court order.
The Guardianship Order
A court guardianship order is obtained by filing Form 70F at the Court of King's Bench (Family Division). A judge evaluates the application against the best interests of the child and, if granted, assigns formal legal decision-making responsibility to the caregiver.
What it gives you:
- Full legal decision-making authority over the child's health, education, and upbringing
- Formal court order establishing decision-making responsibility
- Can include a child support order requiring biological parents to pay through the Maintenance Enforcement Program
- Not revocable by the parent — only the court can vary the order
- Provides legal permanence for stable, long-term arrangements
What it costs:
- Court filing fees (fee waivers available for low-income applicants)
- Possible legal representation costs (Legal Aid Manitoba covers eligible applicants)
- Time — timing depends on the court's schedule and the steps required in the case
- Personal service of documents on all biological parents
Free Download
Get the Manitoba Kinship Money Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
The Financial Side-by-Side
Both paths can support applications for the same financial programs, subject to each program's eligibility rules:
- EIA Section 5(1)(f) child-only grant — available under either arrangement
- Canada Child Benefit — claimable with either as proof of care
- Manitoba Child Benefit — available if receiving CCB and income qualifies, provided the household is not receiving full EIA basic assistance
- Rent Assist — available based on income and housing costs, regardless of legal status
- Child Care Subsidy — available to any eligible household
The guardianship order adds one financial lever the In Loco Parentis form doesn't: enforceable child support from the biological parents through the Maintenance Enforcement Program. If the parents are employed and capable of contributing, a child support order can provide additional monthly income for the child.
When to Choose Each Path
Start with In Loco Parentis when:
- The parents are cooperating and willing to sign
- The arrangement might be temporary (parent is recovering from illness, completing treatment, or stabilizing housing)
- No institution is blocking you from accessing services
- You want financial support quickly without the court timeline
Move to a guardianship order when:
- The parents refuse to sign or can't be located
- A school or hospital won't enroll the child or consent to treatment without a court order
- The biological parents might try to disrupt a stable arrangement
- You want to pursue child support
- The arrangement is clearly permanent and you want legal certainty
The Escalation Path
Many kinship caregivers start with an In Loco Parentis agreement and seek a court order later if circumstances change. This is a normal progression, not a failure. The In Loco Parentis form supports applications for financial assistance while the family sorts out whether court is needed.
If you started with the older Legal Aid Manitoba Guardianship Agreement (pre-2017), it's still valid for EIA purposes. You don't need to replace it with the new In Loco Parentis form unless you're establishing a new arrangement.
The Manitoba Kinship Financial Help Guide walks through both paths in detail — when to use each one, what documents you need, and how to transition from one to the other.
Get Your Free Manitoba Kinship Money Checklist
Download the Manitoba Kinship Money Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.