Florida Probate Court vs. Family Court for Child Custody: Which One Do You Need?

Filing your custody petition in the wrong court division is one of the most expensive mistakes a grandparent or relative can make in Florida. You lose your filing fee (typically $301 to $409), waste weeks waiting for the clerk to process and then reject the filing, and start over in the right division. The confusion is understandable — Florida's circuit courts split child-related cases across three divisions with overlapping terminology.

The Three Court Divisions

Every Florida circuit court maintains specialized divisions for different types of cases involving children:

Family Law Division handles Chapter 751 petitions for temporary and concurrent custody by extended family members. This is where most grandparents and relatives file. You can represent yourself (pro se). The forms are the 12.970 series from the Florida Supreme Court. Filing fees range from $301 to $409 depending on the county.

Probate and Guardianship Division handles Chapter 744 minor guardianships — both guardian of the person and guardian of the property. A guardian must be represented by a Florida attorney under Florida Probate Rule 5.030(a), unless the guardian is a Florida attorney. There is no exception for relatives and no pro se option for a non-attorney guardian, so retain counsel before filing.

Juvenile and Dependency Division handles Chapter 39 cases where DCF has intervened because of abuse, neglect, or abandonment. You can't file here on your own — DCF initiates dependency proceedings. If a dependency case is already open, this court has priority jurisdiction, and you work through this division for relative placement, the Relative Caregiver Program, or permanent guardianship.

Quick Routing Guide

Answer these three questions in order:

1. Is there an open DCF dependency case involving this child? If yes → Juvenile Division. The dependency judge has continuing jurisdiction under Section 39.013(3) and may exercise concurrent authority over related custody or guardianship matters. Don't file a separate Chapter 751 petition in family court — the juvenile judge coordinates everything.

2. Is the child due to receive a net settlement or inheritance over $15,000? If so, a guardian of the property is required under Chapter 744, and that property matter belongs in Probate Division. If you also need custody authority over the child's person, ask an attorney whether a separate Chapter 751 petition is appropriate.

3. Neither of the above? → Family Law Division under Chapter 751. File for temporary custody (Form 12.970(a)) or concurrent custody (Form 12.970(b)). No attorney required. This is the right court for the vast majority of grandparent and relative custody cases.

Why the Distinction Matters Beyond Filing

The court division determines more than where you submit paperwork. It affects:

Attorney costs: Chapter 751 in family court allows self-representation. Chapter 744 in probate court requires an attorney, adding legal costs. Filing in probate when a Chapter 751 petition fits can add an unnecessary attorney requirement.

Background checks: Family court (Chapter 751) leaves background checks to the judge's discretion and local administrative orders. Probate court (Chapter 744) mandates Level 2 FBI/FDLE fingerprinting for all non-attorney guardians at $50 to $75 per person.

Ongoing reporting: A Chapter 751 custody order requires no annual reports. A Chapter 744 guardianship requires annual filings — an Annual Guardianship Plan (person) or Annual Accounting (property) — and missing one can result in the judge suspending your authority.

Financial program eligibility: A Chapter 751 order can support an application for Child-Only TCA through ACCESS Florida, subject to the program's eligibility rules. A Chapter 39 placement through DCF may qualify for the Relative Caregiver Program. A Chapter 744 guardianship, standing alone, doesn't automatically unlock either program.

The "Letters of Guardianship" Confusion

Many relatives search for "letters of guardianship" when what they actually need is a certified copy of a Chapter 751 custody order. Letters of guardianship are a probate-specific document issued under Chapter 744. A certified copy of a Chapter 751 order documents your custody authority; ask each school, provider, or benefits office whether it needs additional paperwork.

If someone at a school or doctor's office tells you they need "guardianship papers," show them your certified copy of the Chapter 751 order and ask which document or additional form they require. A Chapter 751 case does not produce probate Letters of Guardianship.

What If You Filed in the Wrong Division?

If you've already filed in probate when family court may be the right fit, ask the clerk whether the case can be transferred or whether you need to dismiss and refile. An attorney can advise on the procedure and any additional fees in your case.

The Florida guardianship and custody guide includes a court routing decision chart that walks through every scenario — from straightforward Chapter 751 filings to complex situations involving open dependency cases, interstate issues, and mixed person-and-property guardianships.

See more Florida guides →